Compared like with like
Best Mattress Toppers
28 mattress toppers scored on what their makers declare — materials, support, cooling, certifications — and compared only with other mattress toppers. No brand pays to be here.
- 1
Avocado$249–$949Eco Organic Mattress TopperLatexGOTS organicOrganic cottonPressure reliefA90 - 2
Avocado$1,099–$1,759Alpaca Wool Mattress ToppersGOTS organicWool / merinoTemperature regulatingOrganic cottonB89 - 3
Brooklyn Bedding$249–$449Brooklyn Bedding Talalay Latex TopperLatexOrganic cottonBreathable3" profileB86 - 4
Saatva$295–$495Saatva Graphite Memory Foam TopperPhase-change materialOrganic cottonMemory foamConductive infusionB86 - 5
PlushBeds$299–$549PlushBeds Natural Latex TopperLatexOrganic cottonGREENGUARD Gold3" profileB84 - 6
Avocado$5,499–$7,299Grand Luxe Mattress TopperLatexWool / merinoOrganic cottonBreathableB81 - 7Casper$259–$399Casper Foam Mattress TopperPressure reliefBreathableOpen-cell / perforated3" profileC79
- 8
PlushBeds$349–$649PlushBeds Handmade Natural Latex TopperLatexOrganic cotton3" profileCottonC79 - 9
ViscoSoft$109–$189ViscoSoft Select High Density TopperMemory foamGel infusedRemovable coverBamboo viscoseC79
18 more mattress toppers are scored in the Formulate app.
What the score means
Declared quality: built from what each maker states about materials, thermal behaviour, support, function, certification and durability, weighted for mattress toppers. It rewards products that say specifically what they are and what they are made of. It is not a lab test, and a product whose maker states too little to grade is not ranked rather than ranked low. Scores compare mattress toppers only with itself — never a mattress with a pair of earplugs.
Frequently asked questions
What are the best mattress toppers?
Avocado Eco Organic Mattress Topper scores highest of the 28 mattress toppers we compared, at 90/100 (grade A).
How are these mattress toppers scored?
On declared quality: what each maker states about materials, support, cooling, function, certification and durability, weighted for this kind of product and compared only with the same kind. It is not a lab test. Products that state too little to grade are not ranked.
More sleep gear
Scores rate what a product declares, not how it will suit you. Persistent sleep problems are worth raising with a clinician. Some links are affiliate links; they never affect a score.