Skip to main content

Supplement Brands, Ranked

Every brand below has been graded by Formulate's automated rubric — the same ingredient-level analysis we apply to every product, aggregated across each brand's lineup. 64 brands covered.

Pure Encapsulations

367 products scored

B-

Brand score: 82 / 100

NOW Foods

258 products scored

C

Brand score: 73 / 100

Bluebonnet Nutrition

238 products scored

D

Brand score: 65 / 100

Nutricost

170 products scored

B-

Brand score: 82 / 100

Thorne

156 products scored

A

Brand score: 94 / 100

Carlson

141 products scored

F

Brand score: 59 / 100

Doctor's Best

118 products scored

D-

Brand score: 62 / 100

Country Life

109 products scored

D

Brand score: 66 / 100

Nature's Way

106 products scored

D

Brand score: 63 / 100

Natural Factors

90 products scored

D+

Brand score: 67 / 100

Vital Nutrients

88 products scored

D

Brand score: 65 / 100

Garden of Life

86 products scored

B

Brand score: 84 / 100

Life Extension

81 products scored

B-

Brand score: 81 / 100

Nature Made

80 products scored

C

Brand score: 74 / 100

Integrative Therapeutics

65 products scored

D

Brand score: 63 / 100

Herb Pharm

64 products scored

F

Brand score: 57 / 100

Jarrow Formulas

62 products scored

C+

Brand score: 79 / 100

Double Wood

60 products scored

C+

Brand score: 79 / 100

BulkSupplements

54 products scored

C+

Brand score: 79 / 100

Nootropics Depot

50 products scored

B-

Brand score: 82 / 100

Gaia Herbs

50 products scored

D

Brand score: 65 / 100

Codeage

46 products scored

D+

Brand score: 67 / 100

Sports Research

45 products scored

C

Brand score: 73 / 100

MegaFood

38 products scored

B-

Brand score: 80 / 100

New Chapter

38 products scored

C-

Brand score: 72 / 100

Nordic Naturals

34 products scored

C+

Brand score: 79 / 100

Trace Minerals

34 products scored

F

Brand score: 51 / 100

Optimum Nutrition

32 products scored

D-

Brand score: 62 / 100

Solgar

32 products scored

C+

Brand score: 78 / 100

NutraBio

32 products scored

C

Brand score: 76 / 100

Zhou Nutrition

17 products scored

D

Brand score: 65 / 100

BioSchwartz

17 products scored

D

Brand score: 66 / 100

Healthy Origins

17 products scored

D-

Brand score: 62 / 100

Transparent Labs

16 products scored

B-

Brand score: 82 / 100

Nature's Bounty

15 products scored

F

Brand score: 57 / 100

Olly

13 products scored

D

Brand score: 63 / 100

vitafusion

12 products scored

F

Brand score: 51 / 100

Momentous

11 products scored

B+

Brand score: 87 / 100

NatureWise

11 products scored

C

Brand score: 75 / 100

Terra Origin

11 products scored

D+

Brand score: 69 / 100

Complement

9 products scored

C+

Brand score: 77 / 100

Micro Ingredients

9 products scored

D

Brand score: 65 / 100

Swanson

9 products scored

C

Brand score: 73 / 100

Onnit

8 products scored

C+

Brand score: 77 / 100

Performance Lab

8 products scored

C

Brand score: 75 / 100

Live Conscious

8 products scored

D

Brand score: 66 / 100

Kirkland Signature

7 products scored

D+

Brand score: 68 / 100

SmartyPants

7 products scored

F

Brand score: 59 / 100

Vital Proteins

5 products scored

F

Brand score: 57 / 100

Seed

4 products scored

B-

Brand score: 82 / 100

Global Healing

4 products scored

D+

Brand score: 67 / 100

Natrol

4 products scored

F

Brand score: 55 / 100

Physician's Choice

4 products scored

D+

Brand score: 69 / 100

ProHealth Longevity

3 products scored

B

Brand score: 85 / 100

Kaged

3 products scored

D

Brand score: 66 / 100

Qunol

3 products scored

D

Brand score: 66 / 100

Viva Naturals

3 products scored

F

Brand score: 56 / 100

Allergy Research Group

3 products scored

F

Brand score: 58 / 100

Centrum

2 products scored

F

Brand score: 53 / 100

Nested Naturals

2 products scored

D

Brand score: 63 / 100

Gorilla Mind

2 products scored

F

Brand score: 55 / 100

Ritual

1 product scored

D

Brand score: 64 / 100

Culturelle

1 product scored

F

Brand score: 46 / 100

Cellucor

1 product scored

F

Brand score: 59 / 100

Frequently asked questions

How are supplement brands graded?

Each brand's grade is the weighted average of Formulate's ingredient-level product scores across that brand's lineup, rebalanced for ingredient transparency and third-party testing coverage. 64 brands are covered. It is not a paid or sponsored ranking.

Which supplement brand scores highest?

Thorne is currently the highest-graded brand at 94/100 (grade A), based on the quality of its full product lineup.

Does Formulate accept payment from supplement brands?

No. Brands cannot pay to be listed, scored higher, or ranked. Grades reflect only the formulas Formulate analyzes; affiliate links never affect a score.

When were these brand grades last updated?

Brand grades are recomputed whenever the underlying product scores change. They were last reviewed July 2026.

How we grade brands. A brand's score is the weighted average of Formulate's product scores across that brand's lineup, rebalanced for ingredient transparency and third-party testing coverage. See the full methodology.

📬 Get new guides in your inbox

Evidence-based supplement guides, no spam

We send a short digest when new guides drop — nothing else. No affiliate pushes, no sponsored content, unsubscribe anytime.